Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Review & Ratings (2024)

Welcome to our comprehensive review and ratings of Brotherhood Mutual Insurance. In this article, we provide an unbiased assessment of Brotherhood Mutual Insurance, covering key topics such as coverage options, claims process, customer satisfaction, and financial stability.

Our goal is to equip you with the necessary information to make informed decisions when it comes to insuring your faith-based organization or ministry. We strive to be your trusted resource for insurance information, ensuring you have the knowledge you need to protect your mission and congregation.

To find the insurance coverage that best suits your organization’s needs, enter your zip code below. By comparing rates from the best insurance providers, you can secure the coverage you need while saving money. Take a proactive step towards protecting your faith-based organization and enter your zip code now.

What is Brotherhood Mutual?

Founded in 1917 by Mennonite leaders, Brotherhood Mutual has a long history of providing insurance to Christian churches and religious organizations.

Brotherhood Mutual agents can be found throughout the United States. Since its origination, this company has grown to become one of the largest commercial property insurance providers for churches. Brotherhood Mutual’s head office is located at 6400 Brotherhood Way, Fort Wayne, Indiana.

Individuals interested in seeking employment with this company can visit the website to find available Brotherhood Mutual jobs.

While there is not a Brotherhood Mutual agent login tool on the website, Brotherhood Mutual clients can access their accounts online and choose to go paperless. You can also get a quote directly from the website without visiting any of the Brotherhood Mutual Insurance locations.

If you have questions or concerns about your Brotherhood Mutual policy, you can call the brotherhood mutual phone number, 1-800-380-5474, during regular business hours. You can send in an email via the website as well. Brotherhood Mutual also offers flexibility when making payments on your policy. You can make a payment through your online account or by mailing in your payment.

A live chat tool is also available on the website, so you can engage with Brotherhood Mutual right away.

What coverages does Brotherhood Mutual offer?

Brotherhood Mutual offers solid protection for churches through coverages like these:

• Property insurance
• Liability insurance
• Excess liability insurance

With property insurance, you can protect the structure of your church and the property within it as well from covered losses like theft. Liability insurance protects your organization’s financial assets in the event of a lawsuit, and you can even purchase excess liability insurance to further mitigate that risk.

Read more: Best Business Insurance for Churches

Does Brotherhood Mutual offer other insurance products?

You can turn to Brotherhood Mutual if you need any of these insurance products:

• Worker’s compensation
• Accident insurance
• Commercial Auto
• Mission Travel

While you cannot get group health insurance through Brotherhood Mutual, you can purchase protection your church’s employees with a worker’s compensation policy. This coverage can help your employees get the help they need if they encounter any injuries or illnesses while conducting their jobs. Not only does this plan assist your employees, but it protects your church from liability suits as well.

With accident insurance, your organization can help volunteers, children, missionaries, and others cover the cost of an ambulance or hospitalization if there were to be an accident.

If your religious organization regularly uses a vehicle, a commercial auto policy from Brotherhood Mutual can get you the coverage you need to be street-legal, but domestic excursions aren’t the only types of travel protected by Brotherhood Mutual.

In addition, you can purchase mission travel insurance if your church or organization plans on traveling abroad for mission-related events. This coverage includes foreign liability, travel medical, and commercial property.

Does Brotherhood Mutual offer competitive rates?

Sample rates are not offered on the Brotherhood Mutual website, so you will need to get a quote to determine how much property or commercial auto insurance with Brotherhood Mutual could cost you. You can, however, save money with the Brotherhood Mutual deductible reduction discount.

You may be eligible for this discount if you own a Brotherhood Mutual policy and have not filed a claim for at least two years. If your policy is claim free for this long, you could get a $500 reduction on your deductible.

Is it easy to file a claim with Brotherhood Mutual?

If you ever need to file a claim with Brotherhood Mutual, you can do so easily. While no Brotherhood Mutual claims address is listed, you can call 1-800-933-1849 or report your property claim online. Bear in mind that filing a claim can increase your rates.