Main Street America Insurance Review & Ratings (2024)

Main Street America is a reputable insurance company with almost a century of experience in the insurance industry. The company profoundly values its customers and prides itself in offering customizable insurance policies.

Whether you are looking for business or personal insurance policies, Main Street America has tons of options for both. Main Street America business insurance plans include workers’ compensation, flood, contractors, and more. At the same time, the company’s personal insurance has personal liability, personal property, and more.

Main Street America has an “A” A.M. Best rating, and homeowners insurance rates are expected to be around $101 a month or $1,211 a year.

We highly recommend discussing your homeowners insurance options with an insurance agent before deciding on a policy. That conversation will help you weed out any insurance coverages you don’t need. Not yet ready to buy the Main Street America Group insurance? Enter your ZIP code into our free online tool for instant homeowners insurance quotes from companies near you today.

What You Should Know About Main Street America Insurance

Welcome to our comprehensive guide on Main Street America Insurance. Whether you’re seeking auto insurance to protect your vehicle, home insurance to safeguard your property, business insurance to ensure the continuity of your operations, or other forms of coverage, our guide is designed to provide you with the knowledge and expertise you need to make informed decisions.

By entering your zip code below, you can compare quotes from the top insurance providers in your area, enabling you to secure the coverage you need at the most competitive price. Take control of your insurance journey by entering your zip code now and unlock a world of possibilities for savings and peace of mind.

What is Main Street America?

Main Street America Insurance is an insurance company with almost a century of experience in the industry. Originally founded to provide affordable insurance to Grange Fraternity members, Main Street America currently writes more than $1.1 billion in annual premiums.

Take a look at the following table for some quick information about Main Street America Insurance.

Main Street America Insurance Quick Stats

It is also important to note that Main Street America has three phone numbers by which customers can reach the company with questions or concerns. In addition to the general phone number listed above, Main Street America has the following numbers:

• Consumer affairs: (866) 265-7908
• Claims: (877) 4Claims (877-425-2467)

You may also choose to reach Main Street America customer service via mailing or e-mail address.

The company also consists of about eight affiliated insurance companies, including Main Street America Protection Insurance Company.

Main Street America Insurance Coverage Options

As a leading insurance company, Main Street America offers a wide variety of insurance products for businesses and individuals. With so many options to choose from, Main Street America could be a one-stop-shop for all your insurance needs.

Main Street America offers the following insurance policies for individuals:

• Auto
• Flood
• Home
• Condo
• Renters
• Umbrella
• Landlords

Within Main Street’s business insurance policies are:

• Flood
• Bonds
• Umbrella
• Contractors
• Business Owners
• Commercial Auto
• Workers Compensation
• Commercial AgriBusiness

Main Street America prides itself on being a company that will work with its customers to meet their specific and unique needs. This value is reflected in every Main Street America insurance policy, including its homeowners insurance.

There are tons of extra options and coverages to choose from when you purchase a Main Street America homeowners insurance policy. Some of the company’s central homeowners insurance policies include:

• Dwelling Property
• Other Structures
• Personal Property
• Loss of Use
• Personal Liability
• Medical Payments to Others

In addition to these general policies, Main Street America offers a few extra coverages with which you can customize your policy, including:

• Law or Ordinance Coverage
• Valuable Items Protection
• Water Back-Up
• Replacement Cost on Contents
• Extended Replacement Cost Coverage

Because Main Street America values its customers’ ability to customize their plans, they offer even more options by which customers can extend their coverage:

• Homeowners Elite Program
• Home Systems Protection
• Home Cyber Protection
• Identity Theft Coverage
• Service Line

No matter what type of homeowners insurance you need, Main Street America has options for you. Be sure to research your options and discuss your needs with an insurance agent before deciding.

You can start your search by using an online quote tool to find homeowners insurance rates by ZIP code. This will give you a good launch point for the rest of your search.

Main Street America Insurance Rates Breakdown

Determining the exact cost of insurance with Main Street America involves various factors, including the type of coverage, policy limits, deductibles, and individual circumstances. While the article provides an estimate for homeowners insurance rates (around $101 a month or $1,211 a year), specific details for other types of insurance or demographic profiles are not explicitly stated.

It’s important for potential policyholders to understand that insurance costs can vary based on personal factors and coverage choices.

Cost Factors and Considerations

Main Street America Insurance offers a range of insurance products, each with its own set of variables influencing the cost. Auto insurance rates, for instance, are impacted by factors such as driving history, vehicle type, and coverage levels. Homeowners insurance costs depend on the value of the home, location, and chosen coverage options.

To get accurate and personalized cost estimates, individuals are encouraged to use online quote tools provided by Main Street America, consult with insurance agents, and consider bundling policies for potential discounts.

While the article does not provide specific costs for various insurance products, Main Street America Insurance emphasizes affordability and customization. To obtain precise pricing details, potential customers should explore the company’s online tools, engage with insurance agents, and inquire about discounts available for their unique circumstances.

Understanding the factors that influence insurance costs is essential for making informed decisions and securing the most suitable coverage.

Main Street America Insurance Discounts Available

Main Street America Insurance understands the importance of providing cost-effective solutions to its customers. To enhance affordability and encourage responsible behavior, the company offers a range of discounts. Here are some of the notable discounts provided by Main Street America Insurance:

• Multi-Policy Discount: Customers can benefit from bundling multiple insurance policies with Main Street America. Combining, for example, auto and homeowners insurance may result in a multi-policy discount, leading to overall cost savings.
• Safety Features Discount: Main Street America rewards policyholders for taking steps to enhance the safety of their homes and vehicles. Installing security systems, smoke detectors, and other safety features may qualify customers for additional discounts.
• Good Driver Discount: Safe driving is recognized and rewarded by Main Street America. Policyholders with a clean driving record may be eligible for a good driver discount, contributing to lower auto insurance premiums.
• Claims-Free Discount: Customers who have a claims-free history with Main Street America Insurance may qualify for a claims-free discount. This reflects the company’s appreciation for responsible and cautious policyholders.
• Home Renovation Discount: Investing in home renovations and improvements can lead to discounts on homeowners insurance. Main Street America acknowledges the efforts of customers to maintain and enhance the quality and safety of their homes.
• Multi-Car Discount: For households with multiple vehicles, Main Street America offers a multi-car discount. Insuring more than one vehicle with the company can result in reduced premiums for each car covered.
• Renewal Discount: Customers who choose to renew their policies with Main Street America may be eligible for a renewal discount. This loyalty incentive encourages long-term relationships between the company and its policyholders.
• Paid-in-Full Discount: Policyholders who choose to pay their premiums in full, rather than through installment payments, may qualify for a paid-in-full discount. This option provides a financial benefit for those who can make a lump-sum payment.

Understanding the available discounts is crucial for customers seeking to maximize their savings while ensuring comprehensive coverage. It’s recommended to discuss eligibility and specific discount details with an insurance agent to tailor policies to individual needs and circumstances.

Grasping the Claim Process at Main Street America Insurance

Ease of Filing a Claim

Main Street America Insurance offers multiple convenient options for policyholders to file a claim. You can choose to file a claim online, over the phone, or even through their user-friendly mobile app. This flexibility ensures that you can report a claim in a way that suits your preferences and schedule.

Average Claim Processing Time

The average claim processing time with Main Street America Insurance is a crucial factor for policyholders seeking prompt resolutions. While specific processing times can vary depending on the nature and complexity of the claim, Main Street America aims to provide efficient service. It’s advisable to check with your insurance agent for more precise information about claim processing times related to your policy.

Customer Feedback on Claim Resolutions and Payouts

Customer feedback on claim resolutions and payouts is essential for assessing an insurance company’s reliability and customer satisfaction. While the provided content doesn’t include specific customer feedback, it’s advisable to research and read customer reviews and testimonials to gauge how Main Street America Insurance handles claims, including the fairness of their claim resolutions and payout processes.

Revolutionizing Insurance: Main Street America Insurance Cutting-Edge Digital and Technological Features

Mobile App Features and Functionality

Main Street America Insurance offers a mobile app that provides policyholders with convenient access to their insurance information and services. The app likely includes features such as policy management, claim filing, bill payment, and access to digital ID cards. The specific features and functionality may vary, so it’s recommended to explore the app or contact the company for more details.

Online Account Management Capabilities

Policyholders can benefit from Main Street America Insurance’s online account management capabilities, allowing them to access and manage their policies from a web-based platform. These capabilities typically include viewing policy documents, making policy changes, updating personal information, and more. The ease of use and functionality of the online portal can enhance the overall customer experience.

Digital Tools and Resources

Main Street America Insurance likely provides policyholders with digital tools and resources to enhance their insurance experience. These may include educational resources, such as articles and guides, as well as online calculators to help customers assess their insurance needs. Additionally, the company may offer online tools for getting insurance quotes, making it easier for customers to explore coverage options.

How Main Street America Insurance Ranks Among Providers

Main Street America Insurance faces competition from several prominent players in the insurance industry. Here’s an overview of some of its main competitors:

• State Farm Insurance: State Farm is a major competitor known for its extensive range of insurance products, including auto, home, and life insurance. With a vast network of agents and a strong presence, State Farm is a popular choice for many customers. Their emphasis on personalized service and a variety of coverage options makes them a formidable competitor.
• Allstate Insurance: Allstate is another key competitor offering a wide array of insurance products, such as auto, home, and renters insurance. Known for its innovative features and comprehensive coverage options, Allstate competes by providing customers with customizable policies and a user-friendly digital experience.
• Progressive Insurance: Progressive is recognized for its focus on auto insurance but has expanded its offerings to include home, renters, and other insurance products. As a competitor, Progressive stands out for its use of technology, such as the Snapshot program, which tracks driving habits to determine personalized auto insurance rates.
• Geico Insurance: Geico is a major player in the insurance market, particularly in auto insurance. Known for its competitive rates and widespread advertising, Geico has gained a significant market share. The company’s online-first approach and user-friendly platform contribute to its competitive edge.
• Liberty Mutual Insurance: Liberty Mutual is a well-established competitor offering a range of insurance solutions, including home, auto, and renters insurance. With a focus on customer-centric services and customizable policies, Liberty Mutual competes by providing a diverse set of coverage options and personalized support.

These competitors, along with others in the market, contribute to the dynamic landscape in which Main Street America Insurance operates. When choosing an insurance provider, customers often consider factors such as coverage options, pricing, customer service, and digital capabilities.

What are Main Street America’s homeowners insurance rates and ratings?

Unfortunately, we were unable to find specific rates for Main Street America. However, you can expect to pay somewhere around the average homeowners insurance rates in the United States, $1,211 a year or $101 a month.

Through A.M. Best, the insurance industry’s leading rating organization, Main Street America holds an “A” (Excellent) Financial Strength Rating and an “A+” Issuer Credit Rating. Both high scores reflect Main Street’s financial stability and overall dependability as a company.

When you choose an insurance policy with Main Street America, you will likely be satisfied with the company’s policies and customer service.

However, it is always a good idea to look into the Main Street America Group reviews and to check in with your insurance agent before buying an insurance policy. Your agent will help you find the best insurance policy or policies for your specific needs and the best insurance companies for you.